A Minor Pitching Development Note

Jay Yencich · April 18, 2016 at 6:00 am · Filed Under Mariners, Minor Leagues 

First off, I want to thank Marc for taking over the system preview for this season. I’m presently in a phase of my life that’s not particularly conducive to sitting down and writing thousands upon thousands of words of minor league preview each season. This year, in particular, the scheduling looked pretty “nope” early on, but in light of certain happenings and certain concerns the team has going forward, I wanted to bring something to everyone’s attention because I think it could be relevant for us down the line.

One of the narratives to emerge from spring training was that the Mariners, with Iwakuma’s unexpected re-signing, were so flush with pitching that they had the enviable problem of choosing between Nate Karns and James Paxton in the back-end of the rotation. The beginning of the minor league season has further impressed on us that Edwin Diaz is exceeding expectations and could be ready to challenge for a spot soon enough. While the overall depth in the system is rather thin at the high levels (though guys like Ryan Yarbrough and Adrian Sampson probably shouldn’t be overlooked), right now we’re looking outward from a position of relative security. If anything, it’s the bullpen that has given us pause, and rightfully so, with a couple of dudes approaching forty and many of the rest being known as gambles, some of which have already faltered, in the cases of forgotten men Ryan Cook and Evan Scribner.

Let’s back up a moment. One of the recurrent sources of frustration in writing minor league previews is that a past role tends to be a bit more indicative of a future role only in the case of position players. Generally, if anyone is going to move, either to a more or less demanding role on the field, you’re going to hear about it. Less certain is the status of pitching prospects, who could begin starting or stop without much fanfare. One could propose that it’s a side effect of the weird pitching schedules in the Cactus League and no one really noticing or caring at the time, but I bring this up to illustrate a point: The present configuration of the Jackson Generals pitching staff is not something one could have readily predicted.

Sure, the way it begins could potentially lull you into some false sense of security. You look up and see Diaz followed by Yarbrough and figure that it’s likely one of the better one-two, left-right punches you’re going to get, even if the metrics plainly favor Diaz. Thereafter is where it starts to get weird. You have right-handers Sam Gaviglio, Brett Ash, and Dylan Unsworth. If you’re unfamiliar with any or all of those names, I’m not going to fault you. College baseball fans might remember Gaviglio from his days pitching for Oregon State, but they might not remember that we acquired him from St. Louis in exchange for Ty Kelly, the positionless OBP wonder, at the end of 2014. Brett Ash, with all due respect to his friends, family, neighbors, and acquaintances, is Some Guy, a NDFA out of Kansas’ famed baseball powerhouse Washburn College who signed after the ’14 draft and didn’t make a pro start until June of last year when necessity pushed him into the rotation. Dylan Unsworth is from South Africa and his nickname is Sharky and we will love him forever, but he doesn’t possess extraordinary stuff and is a fifth starter at best, and a fringe one.

What is instead “weird” about all this is the sheer number of former starters in the Jackson bullpen. Matt Anderson, a holdover from last year, got the Tom Wilhelmsen treatment and switched to relief on making it to double-A. He remains the same “good fastball, potentially great curveball, sketchy command” guy that he has been previously.

Among the other former starters after him, you have Jordan Pries, who was the big surprise in 2014 as a former 30th round pick who was one of the Rainiers’ best starters down the stretch. The same was not true in 2015, when his ERA caught up to his existing components/stuff (90 mph-ish FB)/pitch to contact approach and he additionally missed the final month+ of the season with an elbow strain.

Or you could look at Stephen Landazuri, who was a long-time sleeper favorite of mine as a guy with a low-90s heater and a good curve. Lando hadn’t relieved in a regular season game since 2012, and while he was quite excellent starting in the Mexican Pacific League over the offseason, his command numbers for both Jackson and Tacoma last year were dire. To boot, he’s had a few recurrent injury issues: biceps strain, oblique strain, missed starts here and there. He’s now pitching out of the Jackson ‘pen as well.

Or we could go with the surprise in Dan Altavilla. Altavilla was fast-tracked up, with a half-season in Everett and a full-season last year in Bakersfield where he showed good stuff and iffy command. People had talked about the possibility of him moving to the bullpen eventually because Major League Baseball scouts have a rather Irken approach to projecting pitchers, but the left-right numbers were solid and the command improved in the second half even as the hits increased a skosh. There was nothing in particular that was projecting him to a doom-and-gloom forecast, and yet here he is now, relieving for the Generals, with the kind of stuff that showed very well as a starter between the slider and the fastball.

Stuff could happen that could push any of the above back into the rotation. “Stuff happening” is one of the inviolable laws of minor league baseball. However, in the case of these three (or four if you feel like including Anderson), the bullpen could present a good career opportunity. Pries was never going to crack in as anything other than an emergency fifth starter and could gain some velocity/Ks from working solely in relief. Landazuri’s command has yet to straighten out for long enough to get you to see him as a three or four and his injury history, while mostly unrelated to the tenderest of the shoulder bits, does not inspire confidence. Altavilla in the bullpen goes from the low-90s velocity he showed as a starter to flashing more in the high-90s as he did in more limited stints and he no longer has to worry about developing a change-up in that role. Whereas a spot in the starting five would have been harder to come by, the bullpen is far less stable moving forward.

Is this experiment likely to work out for everyone involved? Does any minor league experiment ever do that? “Here, try catching.” “Here, try throwing this weird pitch.” “Play this position that you never have before outside of pickup games maybe.” “You can’t hit, but can you throw a knuckleball?” Minor league baseball is silly. However, if it does work out for any of these guys, what you have done is increased their odds of making a big league roster, perhaps minimized the variables they previously had to contend with, and given your team a cost-controlled arm that allows you to maneuver money elsewhere in the roster building process. These aren’t exciting moves, but they look like they could be good for everyone involved. Good work, Mariners.

Late Edit: I wrote this before Landazuri and Pries had poor outings over the weekend, but consider the SSS and the unfamiliarity with the role.


7 Responses to “A Minor Pitching Development Note”

  1. maqman on April 18th, 2016 11:19 am

    The Generals have an interesting arms collection but nothing like the days of the Big 3, which seems to have shrunk to the Big 1. Diaz has the best shot at The Show but he dooesn’t have a guarantee. One or two of the rest might figure things out and get a cup of coffee or even possibly more. Guillermo Heredia and Tyler O’Neill are looking offensively good, the Cuban is looking better than I expected for a bargain buy.

  2. Hutch on April 18th, 2016 1:07 pm

    I would totally be on board with some bullpen reinforcements from the farm, even if it means “fast-tracking” and punting on the remote starting dreams of some of these low-level arms. It’s worked out ok so far, but the major league pen hasn’t exactly filled me with confidence. What’s the best hope for a minor league RP that makes a meteoric rise to the majors this season? Paul Fry? Altavilla? Donn Roach, if he counts?

  3. Sowulo on April 18th, 2016 8:35 pm

    Don’t look now but Zunino was just named PCL player of the week and then went out and added a 2-dinger 4-ribbie day to celebrate. *fingers crossed*

  4. Notfromboise on April 18th, 2016 11:57 pm

    Looks like the Mariners are attempting to be like most teams (finally) and stockpiling as many assets as possible in the minors.

    So either they can bring up guys like Zunino, Roach, Taylor, etc…. Or package them for a team that is in ‘sell now’ mode. Either way, it’s good to have options.

  5. Jay Yencich on April 19th, 2016 7:36 am

    Don’t know how much to make of yesterday though. After all, it was in Albuquerque, the park where Mariners legend Trayvon Robinson once hit 26 home runs over 100+ games.

  6. Jay Yencich on April 19th, 2016 7:38 am

    Fry and Altavilla appear to be the best bets for near-term bullpen contributors. Altavilla’s been serving as the Jackson closer from what I can tell. Fry’s had some runs score against him (two in 3.1 innings) but he’s also struck out five, which is exciting.

  7. Longgeorge1 on April 19th, 2016 8:07 am

    I would not get excited about Zunino. He appears to be a classic AAAA with the bat. We have seen this before. If I could project AAA to MLB I like anyone else would be a billionaire.
    Looking at players in AA is even harder. I have heard/read several times that just about every player in AA has the athletic talent to play MLB. It is the parts you can’t measure (Zunino?) that determine eventual success.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.