Cirillo’s back. I can’t find any information on who got dropped from the roster (Borders?). It’ll be interesting to see if Bloomquist holds on to the hot corner job with Jeff back. As a brief refutation to those of you with little hearts for pupils as you email us about what a dreamboat Willie is, I’d like to point out that we do have a lot of information on Bloomquist in the minors: 155 games at AAA, 123 games at AA, 100 games in A-ball. That’s a significant sample size and during that time he only hit well at Lancaster (A) in 2000. And as to the question of whether Willie is so young that we should expect growth, well, he’s 25. He’s no spring chicken.
Snelling Update: Snelling’s got a torn left miniscus, he’s out for the rest of the year, might be ready for the Arizona Fall League. But he’s not going to be the September call-up we might have been hoping for.
Thanks to reader/e-mailer Jeremy Muck, we’ve just been notified that the Tampa Bay Devil Rays claimed Piatt on waivers. So, the M’s didn’t pass on him, as Tampa was allowed to put in a claim before Seattle was. That said, I’m not losing any sleep over not having Piatt on the roster.
I realize you and Jason are squarely on the Adam Piatt bandwagon, but let me give you some reasons to get off:
1. Adam Piatt is tremendously redundant. He’s made his living off of being a lefty masher who you simply don’t want in the line-up against a right-handed pitcher. From 2000-2002, Piatt has hit .300/.389/.500 vs lefties and .215/.294/.330 against righties. In other words, he’s a pretty good platoon player. However, the M’s already beat the crap out of lefties. .292/.368/.440 for the season, vs .270/.348/.418 vs righties. In particular, Randy Winn, who plays Piatt’s position, is also a nice lefty masher (.317/.368/.511 this year). So, Piatt doesn’t improve the teams weakness, and simply provides depth at a spot where it isn’t needed.
2. He’s an awful fielder. Just awful. We’re talking Butch Huskey awful.
3. Whose roster spot does he take, assuming you want him on the playoff roster? The organization simply won’t dump John Mabry, their main lefty bat off the bench, to bring in a right-hander with a .280 on base percentage.
The M’s need a left-handed bat. The M’s need Matt Stairs.
Piatt Watch: Adam Piatt was designated for assignment on the 13th. Clearing waivers can take 4, 5 days, but at this point we can safely assume Piatt got through and is not going to be claimed by the Mariners. Weirdly, he hasn’t shown up in Sacramento yet, as far as I can determine from reading the transaction wires.
I didn’t see any other interesting floatsam on the wires while I was looking.
Mariners visit Toronto
Tue Aug 19, 4:05p, RHP Franklin v RHP Escobar
Wed Aug 20, 4:05p, RHP Meche v RHP Towers
Thu Aug 21, 4:05, LHP Moyer v LHP Hendrickson
Towers is a former Orioles pitcher who has bounced around the transaction wire a little since his debut. He’s not a huge deal, he’s another servicable back-end starter if things work out for him, and they’ll toss him if he’s not. The story this week is going to be whether the Mariners, busted up and struggling to score, will be able to increase their lead over the A’s, who are 4 games back, and face the same brutal Red Sox lineup the M’s had to face (and, as a bonus, the A’s are facing Lowe-Wakefield-Martinez). We’ve seen this happen before, when the M’s lost to the lowly San Diego Padres in interleague play while the A’s beat up on the Giants, but the Mariners should pick up another game before they head back into Boston to get slapped around by that offense again.
The real story though is the cellar of the AL West, where the Rangers are threatening to take over 3rd place from the Angels. The Rangers are a scary team. Their infield is young and really good: Teixeira-Young-Rodriguez-Blalock is a unit I think I’d swap any other team’s for — they’re young, except for Alex, they’re cheap for now, and they’re hugely productive. All they really need is for the lightbulb in John Hart’s head to go off, and suddenly he’s got the money and the organization to build a contender fast. Meanwhile, the Angels… ugh. They’ve just collapsed this year, it’s ugly.
It’s weird, when you think about it:
Mariners: old club with old-school management, 1st in division
Athletics: younger club with new-school management (with mixed record of following through on new-school), 2nd
Angels: mixed club with old-school management, 3rd in division
Rangers: young club with mixed management (Hart’s fall from being smart about FA/building a team), last in division
Rose update from the Cincinnati Enquirer: “I think Pete’s living up to his end of whatever bargain he made with the commissioner back in November, and that’s in their hands, and he’s just going to sit quiet until something happens, one way or the other,” Schmidt said.
Schmidt mostly echoes MLB’s line in his statements, including the “irresponsible journalism” one, but I think it’s telling the he thinks something’s going to happen and acknowledges that there’s an agreement in place from the November meetings.
Lastest Gammons column has a bit about Rafael Soriano, and this: “Don’t be surprised if Clint Nageotte doesn’t help the Mariners in September,” one NL scout said. “He’s got star closer written all over him.”
Does Clint know this? I’d be pretty hacked off if someone wrote ‘star baseball writer’ all over me while I slept.
Also, “Anyone who knew Bob Melvin and Eric Wedge over the years expected them to be very good managers, which they are.”
Bob Melvin’s not a very good manager. He may be one: there are signs he learns, which is more than you get out of many managers, but at the same time, there are many unanswered questions about his game tactics, etc.
If you played a potted plant at third instead of Zeile, the potted plant will provide approximately equal contributions on offense and defense, and as a bonus, the potted plant produces refreshing oxygen, and everyone loves oxygen.
Carlos Beltran, just to head off more email, isn’t a free agent until after the 2004 season. However, as an arb-eligible player on a team that consistently claims to be cash-strapped, it’s conceivable the M’s could deal for him and his arb contract (offering, we presume, pitching) and then sign him to a massive extension as part of the deal.
Seriously, if Edgar retires, here’s Derek’s Plan B:
– try and get Beltran and, failing that, re-sign Cameron for a 2-3 year deal, even if you have to pay more $$$
– sign Matsui to play SS
– do all the other things you can safely assume I’d do as GM
– win the AL West and the World Series and hold riotous Oktoberfest celebrations in downtown Seattle
– wash crowd control chemicals out of eyes
Zeile’s only offensive contribution right now is a marginal ability to get extra base hits versus lefties. He’s completely useless against right-handed pitching. The M’s kill lefties already and have no need for another lefty-masher. The fact that his resume says “3B” might tempt Melvin into using him there, which would be akin to sticking a potted plant on the third base bag. If the M’s want to punt defense to get a right-handed bat in the lineup at third base, just stick Colbrunn there. He’s just as immovable in the field, but he can actually hit.
Neither option is better than Jeff Cirillo. Caught up in the lynch-mob mentality of Cirillo’s poor hitting is the fact that he’s still the best defensive 3B in the game, and that makes him a contributing member of the team.
Also, a quick Rett Johnson update. The doctors found a cyst on Rett’s right shoulder, which is believed to have been caused by playing football in high school. He’s going to undergo more tests today, and there has been no official confirmation that he’ll be shut down for the year. That, however, seems like the likely path.
